Perception and Reality

Article by: Fred Hoekstra

Worldwide, lameness is the third most costly animal health problem after infertility and mastitis.

Most research on lameness has focused on the housed cow – this is logical as housing tends to increase the prevalence of lameness and, particularly in the US, Canada and parts of Europe, more cows are being housed permanently and access to pasture is being reduced in those cows which are not housed all-year-round.

Many of the risk factors associated with lameness in Northern Hemisphere cattle are not present on most New Zealand dairy farms – this includes such obvious factors as poor cubicle design, and less obvious factors such as higher proportion of cows in good to fat body condition, or mixed grazing of commercial sheep flocks and dairy herds.

The difference between systems means that the impact of lameness is different. In the seasonal system seen on most New Zealand farms the time of year when cows are lame has a major impact on the cost of lameness. Lameness in spring, that is before breeding, is likely to result in significantly greater costs than lameness in the summer.

New Zealand-based data is therefore essential if we are to properly understand, manage and control lameness in New Zealand.

How many lame cows are there?

The proportion of cows that are lame at least once per year (lameness incidence) is not very well known in New Zealand. Farmer records grossly underestimate the percentage of lame cows reporting figures of between 4 and 6%; if farmers are actually asked these figures increase to 9% in the North Island and 16% in the south. These figures are still an underestimate – a prospective study of 43 farms in the South Island which got farmers to actively record their lame cows found that 26.2% of cows were lame at least once per year, with individual farm figures ranging from 4.3 to 64.4%. No similar data are available from the North Island.

However, lameness incidence it is not the only important measure of how many lame cows there are. Probably more important is how many lame cows there are at the moment (lameness prevalence). Measuring prevalence identifies how bad the problem is at the moment and, with incidence, allows the duration of lameness to be estimated. Lameness prevalence can be measured in two ways – asking farmers or lameness scoring. The two results will not be the same (unless the farmer routinely uses lameness scoring) and the difference between the two is important as it is a measure of how well the importance of lameness on the individual farm is being reflected in farmer perception.

Previous research has shown that locomotion scoring can identify between 2.5 to 5 times the number of lame cows identified by farm staff (Wells et al. 1993; Sárová et al. 2011), but all of this data came from housed cattle. Pasture-based cattle have to regularly walk from the field to the parlour to be milked, so it is possible that this provides an increased opportunity to detect lame cows even if they are not being actively looked for.

We tested this hypothesis on 59 dairy farms throughout New Zealand, 33 on the North Island and 26 on the South. Farms were visited at the expected peak for clinical lameness; i.e. October / November in the North and January/ February in the South (Gibbs, 2010). Farmers were asked how many lame cows they had and then the whole herd was locomotion scored, using the 4-point DairyNZ lameness scoring system (lame cows had a score of 2 or 3)

Mean herd prevalence of lame cows as detected by lameness scoring was 8.3% (range 1 to 36%) with 21% of lame cows having a mobility score of 3.  Lameness prevalence as identified by farmers was 2.3% (range 0 to 20%).  There was no difference between islands in lameness prevalence even though the farmer reported lameness incidence was different.  On individual farms the proportion of lame cows identified by farmers ranged 0 to 95% (mean 25%). Farmers who thought they had more lame cows tended to be better at identifying them, but there was no relationship between the number of lame cows identified by lameness scoring and farmer’s ability to detect lame cows.

This study shows that, although both the farmer reported incidence and prevalence of lameness was much lower than that recorded in most similar studies performed in the US and Europe, the proportion of lame cows recognised on these farms (1-in-4) was similar to that reported in previous studies. This suggests that the New Zealand system doesn’t increase the detection of lame cows and that lameness scoring is still required to properly evaluate lameness prevalence.

Farmer estimates of lameness prevalence were very similar to the proportion of cows with a lameness score of 3. This could be the result of farmers being better at recognising more severely lame cows, but farmer estimates of lameness prevalence were more strongly correlated with the number of cows having a lameness score of 2 or 3 rather than just the cows which were score 2 or 3.  This means that farmers are missing both severely and moderately lame cows – consistent with the findings of a single farm study that approximately 15% of severely lame cows were treated >6 weeks after first being recorded as severely lame (using locomotion scoring).

These data clearly show that there is room for improvement in the recognition of lame cows under New Zealand conditions, and also the recording of lameness. Even though lameness prevalence and incidence is relatively low in New Zealand, there is still a significant problem of under-recording of lameness and under estimation of its importance. This has importance at the farm level, where lack of recognition of lameness can be a barrier to control, and also at the industry level, where under-estimation of the importance of lameness can mean it is ignored or only limited resources applied to developing and improving control strategies.

Acknowledgements

Jessica Fabian for all the mobility scoring and the veterinarians who supported her, particularly Neil Chesterton and Mark Bryan.

Richard A. Laven, IVABS, Massey University, Palmerston North Email: r.laven@massey.ac.nz

Richard recently presented this topic at the Lameness in Ruminants 2013 Conference in Bristol, U.K.

Recommended Posts